Western countries ignoring human rights to curry favour with India

July 2023

The recent shocking video of the appalling treatment of two women in Manipur in which they were stripped naked by a mob, groped and possibly gang raped, has shocked the world and forced Narendra Modi to make a statement and take some action. The incident took place in May yet no investigation took place and no arrests made. At the time, Narendra Modi made no comment. Nor was this some kind of isolated incident. The violence by the Hindu Meiki majority on the Christian Kuki minority has involved thousands fleeing their homes, and has been continuing for some considerable time.

Prime Minister Modi has form in this kind of situation. His role in the massacre of thousands of Muslims in 2002 in Gujarat State is well known. The government has a poor human rights record on a number of fronts. All sorts of groups are either banned, closed down or subject to terrorist laws to stifle dissent. Amnesty International has been banned and the BBC offices closed down. Religious organisations have been subject to crackdowns. The country is now 161st of 180 in the press freedom index.

But such is the size of India that it has a high role to play especially as some kind of counterweight to China. Hence Modi being feted in Washington, Paris and London. The desire to sell arms and in the UK’s case, a desperate desire to obtain a post-Brexit trade agreement, that questions about multiple human rights abuses are quietly brushed aside. In Washington, according to the New York Times, one – only one – journalist was allowed to ask Modi a question on democracy in India and apparently, he expressed surprise that the question was asked at all. He is reported to have replied that ‘Democracy runs in our veins. We live democracy and there’s absolutely no discrimination’.

The red carpet was also put out for him in Paris and he was also awarded France’s highest honour the Legion d’Honneur.

The treatment of Modi, the fawning attention and red carpet receptions are part of a trend where the desire for contracts, oil, or the sale of arms, takes precedence over any consideration of human rights. He receives favourable and uncritical coverage by the media in India: not surprising since those critical of him are locked up or otherwise silenced. At least no one uses the phrase the ‘World’s largest democracy’ anymore.

Quite apart from human rights considerations, one has to question the political value of all this fawning treatment. Modi is happily buying oil from Russia in defiance of the embargo. If things get serious with China – over Taiwan for example – does anyone seriously think that he will lift a finger to help? China already occupies many thousands of square miles of Indian territory in the Himalayas and India is powerless to do anything about it. As tensions with China increase, we can expect more and more issues of this nature by Western countries trying to build alliances against its ever increasing power. It will be a matter of sadness however that many of these countries are dictatorships or autocracies with atrocious human rights records. This is simply overlooked in the rush to build such alliances.

UPDATE: 22 July. It is reported 4 arrests have now been made.

Sources: New York Times, Hindustan Times, Amnesty International.