Defend Dissent: How UK Laws, Universities and Tech Curb Our Rights


Various matters of concern to rights in the UK

November 2026

Freedom of Expression in UK Universities

This is the latest in our reports on the human rights situation in the UK. There are many worries about a steady deterioration in these rights with successive governments tightening or restricting controls on assembly and the right to protest, the adoption of Palantir technologies in defence and the NHS (with reports that the firm is seeking access to patient records in GP practices) and threats to privacy with facial recognition being steadily applied.

In an overview of its recent report on freedom of expression in UK universities Amnesty UK concludes that many are adopting restrictive measures that unduly limit studentsโ€™ and academicsโ€™ rights to organise, assemble and express political views, particularly in support of the human rights of Palestinians

Since October 2023, institutions have implemented responses that include prior authorisation for meetings and events, compelled no-protest undertakings, the use of civil injections, and disciplinary action.  These measures are at odds with international human rights law and have a chilling effect on freedom of expression.  Some appear to have been implemented in a discriminatory way.  The cases featured in this report spotlight some of the most prestigious UK universities among others.  They send a clear message to all students and academics that they could face sanctions if the speak out on Palestine or participate in protests.

This report makes recommendations to universities and others who have the power to reverse the trends seen on campus, and reassert the role of universities as places of open enquiry and learning.  The report finds that external pressures from the Department for Education and Office for Students, along with shared security planning through networks such as Universities UK and the Association of University Chief Security Officers, have contributed to the suppression of freedom of expression since 2023.

Amnesty UK has launched a student-led Defend Dissent Campaign alongside the report to push universities to adopt the Defend Dissent Charter, which aims to protest peaceful protest and open enquiry on campus.

A joint investigation by Liberty Investigates and Al Jazeera has revealed that 13 British universities have discussed how to handle pro-Palestinian campus protests with the UKโ€™s largest weapons manufacturer, including ramping up security at events and coordinating responses to criticism, among them the Universities of Manchester, Nottingham, Southampton, Birmingham, Strathclyde, Cranfield, Lancashire, Sheffield Hallam and Cardiff.  Those which are considered โ€˜strategic partnersโ€™ by BAE Systems collectively receive up to ยฃ15 million a year from the company under long-term funding agreements.

Terrorism Arrests/Palestine Action

Recently released Home Office statistics show record numbers of terrorism related arrests in the year to June 2026.  The total number of such arrests was 3,867 up from 234 in the previous year.  The increase can be attributed to the proscription of Palestine Action and the large numbers of people who publicly declared their support for the group in the wake of that decision.  94% of all terrorism arrests that year were linked to this.  At the date of reporting, only 704 results had resulted in a charge, including 634 linked to Palestine Action (Source: UK Human Rights Blog.)

This repression has been forcibly demonstrated by the recent refusal of entry to the UK of Swedish academic Andreas Malm, whose presence the Home Office considers โ€˜may not be conducive to the public goodโ€™.  Malm, an environmental campaigner, supporter of Palestine (but not a member of Palestine Action) and a regular visitor to academic conferences in the UK, was due to share a talk with Huda Ammori, co-founder of Palestine Action.  He says his entry ban is โ€˜scandalousโ€™ and the UK Government should reconsider it. 

The author Sally Rooney is now unable to enter the UK because of the threat of arrest, following her pledge to use proceeds from her works to support Palestine Action, while her publisher Faber could face criminal charges if it passes on to her proceeds from sales. 

Palestine Action has received permission from the High Court to appeal once again against its ban, but only on the grounds of whether the Home Secretary applied her policy directly, not on human rights grounds.  The intervention by Amnesty and Liberty was heard on 4th and 5th November.

Rights of Residence

The Home Office has now lifted the deportation order on Tony Hall, the second-generation Windrush immigrant whose prison sentence ended 25 years ago but who has been unable to start his new life with a deportation order hanging over him.  He was deported to Barbados but was refused entry as he had lived in Britain since he was 12.  He could neither work, get benefits, rent, nor access full NHS treatment and was living in limbo and on his family as a result.

Privacy

A recent Liberty poll found that 48% of people oppose scanning the faces of people walking in high streets and towns when there is no suspected imminent threat, while 41% supported it and 11% were unsure as to its use.  The Met have confirmed that fixed live facial recognition will be put in place in December in the newly pedestrianised Oxford Street.  The Governmentโ€™s commitment to introduce a legal framework through the Police Reform Bill is not expected until the New Year.

(Proposed) Business, Human Rights and Environment Act

Major British supermarkets, including M&S, ASDA and Sainsburyโ€™s, have now joined a campaign calling on the Government to introduce mandatory human rights and environmental due diligence for businesses in both their domestic and supply chains.  Campaign concerns include the use of forced labour, working conditions and pollution, and it would require retailers to identify and prevent environmental and human rights harms.  Currently many business standards are voluntary and the Modern Slavery Act 2015 is seen as significantly limited,  The campaign is supported by the British Retail Consortium, the Ethical Trading Initiative and the Corporate Justice Coalition as well as trade unions, businesses and campaign groups.  Its aim is โ€˜to transform corporate culture for the betterโ€™ and level the playing field for victims of abuses.

Palantir

Country-wide demonstrations against the use of Palantir in the NHS may be having some effect.  The Financial Times reported in October that more than 20 NHS trusts have stopped using Palantirโ€™s waiting list tools, and at least 16 NHS bodies have formally stated through Freedom of Information responses that they do not use Palantirโ€™s Federated Data Platform at all.  It is not clear whether these are new decisions or whether the Government may still renew the contract.

Demonstration in Southampton against Palantir. Photo: Salisbury Amnesty


Security


A significant step forward was made today against the excessive and arguably illegal interception of messages by the secret services and in particular, GCHQ. The hoovering of email, Skype, Facebook and other electronic messaging services was indiscriminate and is likely to have been illegal. Assurances that this surveillance is tightly controlled have been shown to be untrue.

wire tap imageThe ruling by the Investigatory Powers Tribunal (IPT) โ€“ a secretive legal body responsible for monitoring the shadowy world of the UK secret services โ€“ said that GCHQ’s access to (and use of) private communications swept up in bulk by the National Security Agency (NSA) breached human rights laws. This is the first time in its 15-year history that the IPT has ruled against an intelligence agency. The landmark verdict proves that mass surveillance sharing on such an industrial scale was unlawful, and a violation of our rights to privacy and to free expression.

Liberty, Privacy International and Amnesty, brought the case against the agencies, following the disclosures about mass surveillance made by whistleblower Edward Snowden in 2013. Thanks to Snowdenโ€™s revelations, the world is now aware of the extraordinary scale on which US and UK security services intercept and store our digital communications, including emails, messages on social networks and internet histories.

That includes not just the UK getting hold of what the US has picked up in its ‘Upstream’ and ‘PRISM’ programmes (which can cover Google, Facebook and other US-based internet platforms), but the UKโ€™s very own โ€˜full-takeโ€™ Tempora system, which scoops up every single communication that passes through the UK. Itโ€™s very possible that highly sensitive communications between activists around the world have been monitored as part of these programmes. It also seems that journalists have been monitored as well as lawyersโ€™ communications with their clients.

The IPTโ€™s ruling acknowledged that the sharing of these communications between the US and UK governments violated human rights law until the end of last year. But even now the UK government will not publicly accept that these mass surveillance programs even exist.

The government has been playing a cat and mouse game over surveillance โ€“ talking about โ€˜national securityโ€™ while trying to cover up unlawful behaviour in its use of private data.

Secret rules about secret practices

Before this case was brought, there was simply no public information whatsoever about how and when the UK thought it could handle the data which the US had obtained. We had to force them to disclose what turned out to be a puny two-paragraph public summary of those rules during the case.ย  Due to that disclosure, the IPT ruled in December that the sharing of surveillance date between the UK and US is now lawful because there is supposedly enough โ€˜signpostingโ€™ in public about what is going on โ€˜below the waterlineโ€™.

So, that means up until that disclosure, the spying programme broke the law โ€“ but because they revealed a few vague details of how they gather and store that information โ€“ itโ€™s now legal for them to continue doing so.

ย Amnesty International strongly disagree with this decision.

Those forced disclosures made by the government are insufficient and fall far short of making its activities lawful.ย  We wonโ€™t stop here โ€“ we are planning to challenge the earlier ruling at the European Court of Human Rights.ย  But until then, while weโ€™re pleased to see it acknowledged the programme has been unlawful up until very recently, the ruling means that the two spy agencies will retain unrestricted access to global communications with minimal safeguards in place.

We have argued before on this site that we accept that intelligence agencies have to intercept messages in their fight against terrorists and others bent on doing us harm. This interception must be under political control and scrutiny and done on a needs must basis. We also expect the media to keep a close eye on the politicians not least because trust in them is so low.

But what seems to have happened is that scrutiny consists of chats between the Security Commission and the security agencies and that there is a failure by the parliamentary committee to ask searching questions. The press have been largely silent and ineffective. It is no surprise therefore that the general public remain unconcerned about the activities of the security services. โ€˜Iโ€™ve got nothing to hideโ€™ is a popular response. People seemed relaxed to see a reduction in their privacy to secure an imaginary increase in their security. Stories are frequently told of terrorist plots being uncovered by the use of such methods.

The bizarre thing is that if one asks the question of someone โ€˜do you trust politicians?โ€™ you are likely to receive a ribald answer (or a black eye). Yet we seem to.

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑